Cover image: Temp love: when the edit is cut to a track you can't use in white on a dark background.

SAWDUST / BLOG

Temp love: when the edit is cut to a track you can't use

Temp love is when a team falls for the temporary track an edit was cut to, and the brand cannot license it. The way out is to name what the team actually loves, such as the tempo, where the music enters and its texture, and brief that. Copying the track, or its singer, is where the legal risk starts.

What is temp love?

Editors rarely cut in silence. To pace a rough cut, they drop in an existing track: something from a playlist, a film score, a record the director had in mind. That temporary music is the temp track. In a 2002 report on advertising practice, the trade publication SHOOT described the temp track as a copyrighted song used "for the purpose of editing and presenting a prospective commercial to the client", and noted that it "frequently becomes the 'guide' for the musical direction given to the composer."

Temp love is what happens next. The agency, the brand and the director have watched the cut forty times with that track underneath it. Every cut point lands on its beat. When the licence turns out to be unaffordable, refused or simply unavailable in time, anything else sounds wrong, not because it is worse, but because the picture was built around something else.

Why does a temp track feel impossible to replace?

The edit has been shaped to the track. Shot lengths follow its bar lengths. The product reveal sits on its drop. A pause in the voiceover sits in its breakdown. Remove the music and the picture still carries the old track's structure.

It means the team rarely loves the song as a whole. It loves a set of things the song does to this particular cut: a tempo the shots were trimmed to, a moment where the music opens up, a texture that makes the product feel a certain way. Those things can be described, and anything that can be described can be briefed.

Can you make a sound-alike of the temp track instead?

This is the most tempting shortcut and the riskiest. Two well-known cases from the United States show why. In one, the agency had licensed the song itself. In the other, the agency knew the risk. Neither avoided a lawsuit.

In Midler v. Ford Motor Co. (Ninth Circuit, 22 June 1988), Ford's agency Young & Rubicam wanted Bette Midler's recording of "Do You Want To Dance" for a commercial. Midler declined. The agency hired a singer who had been one of Midler's backup singers for ten years and told her to "sound as much as possible like the Bette Midler record." The court noted that "Young & Rubicam had a license from the copyright holder to use the song." That licence did not settle the matter. The court held that when "a distinctive voice of a professional singer is widely known and is deliberately imitated in order to sell a product", "the sellers have appropriated what is not theirs and have committed a tort in California", and sent the case to trial.

In Waits v. Frito-Lay (Ninth Circuit, 1992), the agency Tracy-Locke pitched a Doritos commercial to its client and "played Waits' recorded rendition of "Step Right Up" to demonstrate the feeling the commercial would capture." It then hired a singer who could "capture the feeling of "Step Right Up" but also imitate Tom Waits' voice." The court's record shows the people making the commercial saw the problem: its musical director warned the singer he "sounded too much like Waits, which could pose legal problems", and the Tracy-Locke staff responsible "were familiar with the Midler decision." The jury awarded Waits "$375,000 compensatory damages and $2 million punitive damages for voice misappropriation" (United States dollars), and the appeal court affirmed those awards, while setting aside a separate $100,000 award under federal trademark law.

The Waits case is temp love in its plainest form: a recording used to sell the idea to the client, followed by an attempt to recreate it. Both cases turned on imitating a famous voice under California law, not on copying a melody. A sound-alike that borrows a song's melody or arrangement raises a separate copyright question.

How do you work out what the team actually loves?

Sit the decision-makers down with the cut and the temp track, and ask them to point at moments rather than adjectives. "It feels premium" cannot be briefed. "The music drops out for a second before the logo" can. Then translate each answer into something a composer or music supervisor can search for.

What the team says What is actually doing the work How to brief it
"It has energy" Tempo and how busy the drums are The tempo in beats per minute, and whether the energy builds or starts high
"It hits at the right moment" Where the music changes against the picture Timecodes for the entry, the lift and the ending
"It feels premium" Space, restraint and sound quality How sparse the arrangement is, and where the voiceover needs room
"It sounds like us" Texture, era and attitude Instruments, production sound and references described in words
"The vocal makes it" The vocal's role in the cut Whether you need a vocal at all, or a hook that does the same job

Keep the temp track out of the final brief as a file to copy. Use it only to pull out these answers. Our guide to writing a music brief for an ad or brand film has a one-page template you can fill in from this table.

How do you replace a temp track without re-cutting the film?

Treat it as a search for tracks that fit the cut's structure, not the temp's sound.

  • Lock the timing map. Write down every timecode where the edit depends on the music: first cut, reveal, end frame. These are the points a replacement must hit.
  • Name the tempo range, not one number. A replacement a few beats per minute away can be stretched or the cut trimmed by a few frames. A track at a very different tempo cannot.
  • Look for a different route to the same feeling. If the temp used a big vocal, an instrumental that opens up at the same moment may do the job without inviting comparison.
  • Audition against the picture, not in isolation. A track that sounds flat on its own can lift a cut. A track that sounds brilliant alone can fight the voiceover.
  • Re-cut a little if needed. Moving three edits by a few frames is cheaper than forcing music to fit a structure it was never written for.
  • Check the licence before anyone gets attached again. Confirm the rights for the replacement before it goes in front of the client. Otherwise the cycle starts over.

Hypothetical example: a 45-second trainer launch is cut to a temp with a heavy half-time beat and a vocal hook on the product shot. The team says it loves "the attitude". On review, what it loves is the drop to almost nothing two seconds before the product appears, and the hit on the logo. The brief asks for instrumental electronic music in a similar tempo range, with a clear break at 0:31 and a hard ending at 0:44. Three candidates are auditioned against the cut. The chosen track has no vocal and sounds nothing like the temp, but it hits both moments, and the editor moves one shot by six frames.

Whether the answer is a licensed track or new music written for the cut is its own decision. We cover the trade-off in custom music or a licensed track for your campaign.

How do you stop temp love happening on the next film?

The cheapest fix is upstream. In the same SHOOT report, the Association of Music Producers (AMP), writing from New York, set out guidelines: "AMP recommends that discussions of direction be limited to musical styles or genres", and existing recordings, or "needle drops", should be kept out of the presentation process "unless licensing of the recording is intended." A past president of AMP told SHOOT: "an editor cutting to a temp track should not send the spot with that track to the music house."

In practice that means three habits:

  • If a track might end up in the film, check whether it can be licensed for this use, and roughly what it would cost, before the edit is built around it. Our guide on how to license a song for a commercial walks through who to ask.
  • Cut early edits to music you could actually use, so the version the client falls for is one you can ship.
  • Describe direction in words from the first brief: tempo, texture, where it lifts. Then a temp track is a reference, not a promise.

Sawdust is a music licensing partner for brands, matching underground electronic music to their values, personality and creative direction. If an edit is waiting on music it cannot keep, tell us about the cut and what the team loves about it.

This is general information, not legal advice.

SAWDUST

BASED IN

Singapore

Sawdust is operated by Armaku,
a music publishing company based in Singapore.

Sawdust is operated by Armaku,
a music publishing company based in Singapore.

© Sawdust 2026